Supreme Court rules burden of proof rests on illegal migrants seeking relief from removal

The Supreme Court shot down on Thursday a bid from an illegal immigrant trying to avoid deportation.

The high court ruled that illegal migrants hold the burden of proving that they have not committed a crime of “moral turpitude” when seeking relief from removal, Breitbart reported.

SCOTUS says no

The case centered on Clemente Avelino Pereida, an undocumented immigrant who came to America from Mexico 25 years ago. He was convicted in Nebraska with a misdemeanor for falsifying a Social Security number to work and was sentenced to a $100 fine and no jail time.

Pereida has faced deportation since 2009, according to reports, and has a wife and three children, one of whom is in the country illegally, and one of whom is a U.S. citizen.

The Justice Department can provide relief for removal when a crime of moral turpitude has not been committed, but Pereida’s criminal record did not make clear whether he committed such a disqualifying offense.

According to Breitbart, the court ruled 5–3 against Pereida, holding that the burden rests with illegal immigrants to prove that they have not committed crimes of moral turpitude. Justice Neil Gorsuch, writing for the majority, said that an appeals court had correctly decided that Pereida failed the test.

“The INA [Immigration and Nationality Act] expressly requires individuals seeking relief from lawful removal orders to prove all aspects of their eligibility. That includes proving they do not stand convicted of a disqualifying criminal offense,” Gorsuch wrote.

“The alien bears the burden”

Of course, illegal immigration is itself a crime, although it’s seldom treated as such by liberals, whether they’re in the White House or sitting on the Supreme Court itself. Three of the high court’s justices — Stephen Breyer, Elena Kagan, and Sonia Sotomayor — dissented.

Breyer wrote that Pereida should stay because of a lack of clarity as to whether he committed a disqualifying offense. “The relevant documents, in this case, do not show that the previous conviction at issue necessarily was for a crime involving moral turpitude,” he said, according to the Associated Press.

However, Gorsuch said that such ambiguity should not “redound to his benefit” and that he still has the burden of proof.

“And where, as here, the alien bears the burden of proof and was convicted under a divisible statute containing some crimes that qualify as crimes of moral turpitude, the alien must prove that his actual, historical offense of conviction isn’t among them,” Gorsuch wrote.

Justice Amy Coney Barrett recused herself from the case because it predated her joining the court.

Share on facebook
Share To Facebook

Welcome to our comments section. We want to hear from you!

Any comments with profanity, advocacy of violence, harassment, personally identifiable information or other violations will be removed. If you feel your comment has been removed in error please contact us!

6 Responses

  1. About time. In our country (unlike others) there is a presumption of innocent until proven guilty ( unless you are republican). He was found guilty and that is where it should rest, he had his chance and could not prove he was innocent therefore the Supreme Court did it’s job.

  2. Why was this illegal not deported? He’s been living in the USA “illegally” for many many years. It’s absurd that he never bothered to become a citizen and should not be allowed to stay in the USA . The laws should apply to everyone equally when you are a citizen, not when you broke the law to enter our country!
    What I saw this past week at the border, due to Nazi Biden sending everyone t-shirts. is reprehensible! The rule of law and closed borders is what a sovereign nation like the USA must hold firm on! God save America from this liberal madness!

  3. You Might Like
  4. Amen to all above posts! Our attorney generals in every state need to file suit to block joebama’s open border scheme! He is endangering our country and legal citizens, and for what? He could care less about them, or our country’s sovereignty! Destroy the USA is his goal! This must stop NOW!

  5. Excellent post. Thanks pertaining to sharing these details. It’s really of great be an aid to me. From a person’s article, I know extra in this particular respect. I may continue paying attention to your write-up.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest Posts